When Insurance Companies Send Payment and EOB's to the wrong office (repeatedly despite informing them of their mistake)

When Insurance Companies Send Payment and EOB's to the wrong office (repeatedly despite informing them of their mistake)

April 16, 20253 min read

Ever had that awkward moment when you realized your patient's insurance payments—and their sensitive information—ended up at an entirely different dental office? It’s kind of like receiving your neighbor’s Amazon package, but instead of garden hoses and air fryers, it’s your patient's dental treatment history and a check that should have been yours. Thanks a lot, United Concordia!

A Comedy of (Serious) Errors

Insurance companies like United Concordia sometimes get confused. Sure, dentistry is complex—but matching the right dentist to their rightful payment shouldn't feel like solving a Rubik's cube blindfolded. When an insurer repeatedly sends checks and explanation of benefit statements (EOBs) containing Protected Health Information (PHI) to the wrong dental practice, things stop being funny and start feeling like an episode of "Dental Office Nightmare."

HIPAA: Not Just a Funny Acronym

While "HIPAA" might sound like something you yell after winning a dental trivia contest (or after pulling off that tricky extraction without breaking a sweat), it’s actually a powerful federal regulation. HIPAA—the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act—has strict rules against insurance companies sending patient records on accidental scenic tours of unrelated dental offices.

And just when you thought HIPAA couldn't get any more intimidating, there's also its muscle-bound cousin, the HITECH Act. This act amplifies the penalties insurers face for privacy violations—think of it like HIPAA, but after three cups of espresso and a motivational TED Talk.

What's the Big Deal Anyway?

Let's get real for a second: These aren't simple clerical mistakes. Every wrongly sent EOB and check exposes sensitive patient information—diagnoses, procedures, treatment plans—information that patients trust you to guard more fiercely than your favorite dental instrument. When insurers fumble this badly, patient trust can erode faster than cheap composite filling material.

Your Step-by-Step Game Plan (Humor Included)

  1. Write 'Em Up: Send a letter to the insurance company demanding they fix their internal GPS. You know, the one currently routing checks through Timbuktu instead of your office.

  2. Call in the Big Guns: File a complaint with the Office for Civil Rights (OCR). Think of OCR as the dental office manager of insurance regulation—they handle problems so you don't have to.

    Pro Tip: Filing with OCR isn't just satisfying; it can lead to actual penalties for repeat offenders. Revenge (served cold or hot) is optional.

  3. Transparency Alert: Inform your patients if their data has wandered. After all, it's their records—and nobody likes surprises, unless it’s free teeth whitening.

  4. State Insurance Commissioner to the Rescue: If federal intervention isn't enough, your state’s Insurance Commissioner is there to lay down the law, literally.

  5. Get Legal (If Necessary): Sometimes you have to bring in legal support to make sure insurance carriers understand you're serious—lawyer serious.

Penalties Are No Joke

Did you know that HIPAA violations can cost insurers up to $50,000 per incident? That's enough to buy about 1,000 new curing lights or roughly 5,000 trendy coffee mugs branded with "Floss Like a Boss."

Takeaway: Don’t Just Grin and Bear It

Insurance companies messing up your patients’ privacy isn’t just irritating—it’s illegal. So, if you find yourself dealing with insurers turning your patients’ PHI into postcards for other offices, don’t laugh it off (okay, maybe chuckle once). Take action, protect your patients, and let insurers know your office isn’t a matchmaking service for lost dental claims.

Stay vigilant, protect your practice, and remember—when dealing with insurance, a good sense of humor is your second most powerful weapon. (The first, of course, is a well-worded letter from your attorney.)


Benjamin Tuinei

Founder - Veritas Dental Resources, LLC
Phone: 888-808-4513

Services:
PPO Fee Negotiators | PPO Fee Negotiating | Insurance Fee Negotiating
Insurance Credentialing | Insurance Verifications

Websites:
www.VeritasDentalResources.com | www.VerusDental.com

Benjamin Tuinei is a leading expert in PPO strategies and fee negotiations, recognized by multiple state dental associations and continuing education institutions. Since beginning his dental career in 2007, he has helped over 9,000 dentists improve insurance reimbursements, influencing more than $5 billion in negotiated revenue. His expertise in restructuring billing departments increased collections from 65% to 98%, and his negotiation skills with third-party payors boosted insurance revenue by nearly $1 million, earning widespread recognition from dental practices across several states.

Benjamin Tuinei

Benjamin Tuinei is a leading expert in PPO strategies and fee negotiations, recognized by multiple state dental associations and continuing education institutions. Since beginning his dental career in 2007, he has helped over 9,000 dentists improve insurance reimbursements, influencing more than $5 billion in negotiated revenue. His expertise in restructuring billing departments increased collections from 65% to 98%, and his negotiation skills with third-party payors boosted insurance revenue by nearly $1 million, earning widespread recognition from dental practices across several states.

LinkedIn logo icon
Back to Blog

© 2025 Veritas Dental Resources | All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions